Need a replacement LCD for my Access Virus Indigo 2

My inexpert analysis is that Crystalfontz does not have an exact match in the white on blue style. Perhaps customer support can give you help.

Meanwhile, you can browse the 16x2 products here:

I expect that any of the CFAH1602 type displays would be electrically and software compatible, but you would have to make some physical adapter to mount them in your panel. This might be as simple as a sheet of thin plastic with holes punched in the proper places.